A former songwriter for Mariah Carey alleged her story in the back of the introduction of smash hit All I Need For Christmas is nothing but a lie.

In a contemporary episode of the podcast Sizzling Takes & Deep Dives with host Jess Rothschild, Grammy award winning songwriter Walter Afanasieff discussed his career and the lengthy collaborative relationship he had with Carey.

Both Carey and Afanasieff are credited for the music. Yet up to now Carey claimed that she wrote the track by means of herself as a younger woman.

“I’m happy with this song that I wrote mainly as a kid on my little Casio keyboard,” Carey instructed Billboard in 2017.

On the podcast launched Thursday, Rothschild requested Afanasieff for his facet of how the song got here to be.

“At the moment, we had been both on the identical actual web page of how we wrote All I Want for Christmas is You,” Afanasieff stated. “There was by no means any ulterior or alternate story, alternate universe, alternate fact, until most definitely 10 years in the past.”

“When she began to type of like hint at the fact that, ‘Oh yeah, I wrote that song once I was once a little bit woman.’ Like, however why weren’t you pronouncing that for 12 or 13 or 15 years previous to that? So it just kind of, form of developed in her thoughts,” he said.

Afanasieff went on to argue Carey doesn’t have the musical chops to had been ready to write such a complicated music.

“However she doesn’t play anything else. She doesn’t play keyboard or piano or she doesn’t consider song,” he stated.

“She doesn’t understand chord modifications in song conception or the rest like that. She doesn’t recognize a diminished chord from a minor seven chord to a major seven chord. I mean, all of the issues that you wish to be aware of although you don’t comprehend, at the least wish to recognize the right way to play that,” he brought.

“To be able to claim that she wrote an extraordinarily sophisticated chord-structured tune together with her finger on a Casio keyboard when she was once a little bit lady. It’s roughly a tall tale. I mean, it’s like, yeah — it’s a tricky track,” Afanasieff mentioned.

Afanasieff went on to give an explanation for that the tune was written 50/50 between him and Carey while the pair had been developing an entire Christmas album and determined to write three originals for the file.

According to Forbes, the tune All I Need For Christmas is You has generated $2.5 million dollars in annual royalties considering its preliminary liberate in 1994.

Hear above by way of Sizzling Takes & Deep Dives.

The publish Mariah Carey’s Former Writing Associate Says She’s Lying About Creation of Hit Track ‘All I Want For Christmas is You’ first regarded on Mediaite.